The First "Golden Bachelor" Couple Is Getting Divorced After Just Three Months

What seemed like a whirlwind romance under the spotlight of reality TV has ended with fans and critics once again questioning the authenticity of the "Bachelor Nation" approach to love.

Gerry Turner, branded as a loving widower and retired restauranteur on the show, proposed to financial services professional Theresa Nist, concluding the wildly successful "Golden Bachelor" kickoff. Turner and Nist had similar personal histories that drew them together. Both were married for more than 40 years to their high-school sweethearts before experiencing the loss of their spouses to health problems.

In the season finale, Turner told Nist, “You’re not the right person for me to live with,” before pausing dramatically. “You’re the person I can’t live without," he added. The couple then raced to have a lavish ceremony in January that was attended by hundreds, including several alumni of “The Bachelor” franchise.

Sadly, however, they announced the dissolution of their marriage in an awkward "Good Morning America" interview.

“We’ve come to the conclusion that it’s probably time to dissolve our marriage,” Turner explained in the interview, shocking the hosts. They also said they were nervous about how fans would react to the news since they'd hoped the show would help older singles believe in finding love.

Apparently, a big part of their decision was their inability to decide where to live. Nist lives in New Jersey, while Turner is from Indiana, and neither could reach an agreement on where to settle.

“The thing that strikes me the most has been how dedicated we are to our families,” Turner added. “We just feel like it’s the best, for the happiness of both of us, to live apart.”

Commentator Allie Beth Stuckey didn't mince words on the subject. She stated that the failure of their marriage not only shattered the illusion of late-life romance but also raised doubts about the sincerity of their "love."

Recent revelations about Turner's life before the show also raise some questions about his integrity. Contrary to the sympathetic portrayal of a widower seeking love after decades of solitude, compelling reports from his friends and family suggest that Turner's dating history is more extensive than he portrayed. In particular, his alleged relationship with a woman named Carolyn initiated very shortly after his wife's passing, paints a different picture of his romantic pursuits. Carolyn also claims Turner refused to take her to a high school reunion because of her weight and dumped her soon after.

Some discrepancies in Turner's professional background also challenge the narrative of "a charming retired restaurateur seeking a new lease on love." In reality, he was actually a maintenance man at a counseling office and hasn't owned a restaurant since 1985 after selling his Mr. Quick Hamburger drive-in franchise.

Stuckey added that one of the glaring problems with starting relationships on television is the temptation to always appear more impressive than you really are.

The fallout from Turner and Nist's failed marriage serves as a cautionary tale for reality TV romances. While the allure of finding love in a glamorous whirlwind captivates audiences, the swift unraveling of most relationships from "The Bachelor" franchise reminds us of the importance of real, committed love rather than fleeting romance.

Evie deserves to be heard. Support our cause and help women reclaim their femininity by subscribing today.