Third Graders Plead With California School Not To Allow Males In Bathrooms, Board Members Dismiss Concerns
At a recent Palo Alto Board of Education meeting, two young girls, along with several parents, voiced concerns about the district’s decision to replace all traditional boys' and girls' bathrooms with "gender-neutral" facilities at Herbert Hoover Elementary School.
At the Palo Alto Board of Education meeting, two young girls stood at the podium, their heads barely reaching the microphone. They were nervous, yet determined to be heard. Both girls shared how uncomfortable they felt using shared bathrooms, expressing feelings that should be far from a child's experience. One girl shared how she had been physically assaulted by a boy in a gender-neutral bathroom, but her plea for protection was ultimately dismissed by the board.
The board’s current policy involves installing multi-stall, gender-neutral bathrooms that share a communal sink area in the school’s upcoming renovation. However, the backlash from the community includes concerns about privacy and safety, especially for younger students.
Parents in the audience, many of whom had expressed similar concerns privately, watched as their children bravely shared what no child should have to worry about. Despite the emotional pleas, the board’s response remained focused on "inclusivity" before shifting the focus to the "cleanliness" of the restrooms. This reaction only fueled frustrations, as many parents and children feel important concerns are not being addressed.
Parents have started a petition calling for a combination of gender-separated and gender-neutral bathrooms to address safety issues. Some students expressed discomfort using the current communal restrooms, leading to further pressure on the board to reconsider its approach. Despite these complaints, the board has not yet shifted its stance.
The girls' testimonies come amid growing debates about the safety implications of gender-neutral restroom policies, especially in schools, thanks to the Biden-Harris Administration's dismantling of Title IX protections for girls and women.
This situation in Palo Alto echoes larger national conversations about "inclusive" policies that undermine the privacy and safety of women. There is increasing pressure to find solutions that also prioritize the safety and comfort of all students rather than only focusing on accomdating male students who want access to female-only spaces.
Subscribe today to get unlimited access to all of Evie’s premium content.